The perils of pricing innovation and the dangers of fixed-price promises

In the dynamic landscape of business, where innovation and agility are at the forefront, the approach to pricing, especially in contracts involving novel or complex deliverables, is fraught with challenges. This is particularly true for projects within lean startups or those with a significant technological innovation component, where there is scant historical data to inform cost and time estimations. The allure of fixed-price contracts, with their promise of budget certainty, can quickly become a perilous pitfall for both providers and clients when venturing into uncharted territories of product development.

The Complexity of Novel Projects

When dealing with projects that aim to bring something entirely new to the market, or when the project team is navigating the development process for the first time, the uncertainty multiplies. This dual novelty—of the product itself and the team’s inexperience with it—complicates the ability to accurately predict the project’s trajectory. Unlike replicating or slightly modifying existing products (like baking another chocolate cake following a well-trodden recipe), innovating (such as creating a never-before-seen dessert) lacks a clear path or precedent, making fixed pricing not just difficult but potentially misleading.

The Dangers of Fixed-Price Promises

Fixed-price contracts, while seemingly offering a safety net of predictability, often lead to a minimization of committed deliverables within that price cap. Anything beyond the initial scope typically triggers change control processes, inflating costs unpredictably. This scenario is not uncommon; vendors may underbid to win contracts, fully aware that the actual requirements will exceed the scope of their initial quote. They rely on subsequent change requests to recoup costs and secure profits, exploiting the gap between the client’s expectations and the evolving reality of the project’s needs. This practice not only strains client-vendor relationships but also introduces significant risk and uncertainty into projects, countering the very premise of fixed-price stability.

The Gap Between Hope and Reality

The stark difference between the hopeful optimism of a fixed-price contract and the practical realities of project execution cannot be overstated. The initial low price becomes a mirage as the true complexity and evolving nature of the project come to light, often leading to a reassessment of needs and a surge in costs due to changes. This gap represents not just a financial or operational challenge but a fundamental misunderstanding of the nature of innovation. Innovation, by its very nature, is exploratory and uncertain, making any attempt to rigidly define its cost and timeline at the outset a gamble.

Navigating Forward

The key to managing the inherent uncertainties of innovative projects may not lie in avoiding fixed-price contracts altogether but in fostering a deeper understanding and flexibility within them. This could involve:

  • Dynamic Pricing Models: Adopting pricing models that allow for adjustments based on project milestones, emerging requirements, and unforeseen challenges.
  • Transparent Communication: Ensuring open lines of communication between clients and vendors to manage expectations and address changes proactively.
  • Collaborative Risk Management: Sharing the risks associated with innovation, possibly through contracts that balance fixed and variable pricing elements based on project outcomes.

In conclusion, while fixed-price contracts offer the allure of budget certainty, their application in the context of innovation requires careful consideration. The unpredictable nature of developing novel products or services demands a more flexible, transparent, and collaborative approach to contract structuring. By acknowledging the perils of fixed pricing in innovation, businesses can better navigate the complexities of bringing new ideas to fruition, ensuring that the journey from concept to reality is marked by partnership rather than contention.

Tim HJ Rogers
Consult | CoCreate | Deliver

I support people and teams to grow, perform and succeed unlocking potential as a partner Consultant, Coach, Project and Change Manager
Together we can deliver projects and change, and improve the confidence, capacity, drive and desire of the people I work with.

ICF Trained Coach | MBA Management Consultant | PRINCE2 Project Manager, Agile Scrum Master | AMPG Change Practitioner | Mediation Practitioner | BeTheBusiness Mentor | 4 x GB Gold Medalist | First Aid for Mental Health | Certificate in Applied Therapeutic Skills

#people #process #performance #projects #programmes #pmo #change #processimprovement #projectmanagement #changemanagement #workshops #mediation #coach #icfcoach #mentor #facilitation #training #jersey #channelislands